Despite constantly hearing this
advice, I read this story my sophomore year of high school (and receiving a
terrible grade on my final paper may I add), I had a closed mind that I would
find the same crushing despair I found then. Memories of Pangloss’ ridiculous
optimism, Candide’s lack of any luck, and the exorbitant number of unrealistic
close-call deaths left a sour taste in my mouth. I do appreciate my mom and her
loving advice, but her optimism has always seemed to be, at least to me, more
of the Pangloss-ian type.
Thus, when I began my reading
journey it was definitely a rough commencement. I fought with myself and
considered procrastinating until much later, but finally I had to conquer my
fear of this novel.
Boy was I surprised. Oh how I
easily forgot what 3 years of extra experience adds to one’s perspective.
I found this perspective when
Candide and Cacambo reached the elusive country of El Dorado. This is a place
that counteracts many of their previous impressions of their world. In this place,
the children at the schoolyards play with gold, emeralds, and rubies as if they
were mere toys. Candide attempted to pay for food with a couple of blocks of
gold, which would be worth thousands in his world, but the people merely
laughed at him. To them, he was throwing dirt on the table for payment. But
yet, when they took some of this ‘dirt’ home with them, the pair could easily
live off of what they had. Furthering their confusion they could not understand
how neither a parliament nor prison existed, but a vast math and science
gallery was nearly in its place. The narrative at this point makes it seem as
if Candide’s head was about to explode.
What was this confusion from? Expectations. Candide and Cacambo had
the expectation that these “precious jewels” would be respected and yearned
after just like in their world. They had the expectation that everywhere in the
world should have a place of punishment for those who do wrong, and not enough
room for all of the intellectuals. On a side note, worst of all, Candide
definitely had the expectation that Cunegonde would look just as beautiful as
she did before he had to leave her. Luckily, when their expectations were
shattered, they were able to learn and utilize this. They learned that not
everything has innate value, like the gold. They learned that not everyone
remains constant. I know I may be assigning lessons to the characters that are
from the mind of Voltaire, but this is what the passage caused me to pause and
think about.
To me, expectations are inevitable
as human nature. I especially had the high expectations of being disappointed
by this novel, but luckily these disintegrated once I began fully diving into
the book. Honestly, surprises are my favorite part about reading books a second
time; I love having the opportunity to see new things with new eyes. I do have
to admit my mom was right: when I keep an open mind, I do have the opportunity
to learn more than I ever expected.
Hi Taylor, Lovely response, thanks. I agree that we are conditioned by our expectations. In many ways, we are what we expect. I think this is indeed what Voltaire was getting at when he described El Dorado. Value is always contingent on context, and what is valuable in one context might not have the same value in another. As you stated, value is not innate or inherent; it is variable. Connected to this notion is the idea that our expectations are shaped by our values, which at best our contextually determined. We are where we are. Thanks for the thoughtful post. Glad I got your blog added. dw
ReplyDelete